Сюжет в клипе хоть и прослеживается, но довольно невнятно. Технически клип слабенький, попадаются удачные моменты, которые автор к сожалению не смог до конца реализовать. Песенка вполне приятная, но этого для хорошего клипа мало. 4.5/10
Ahhh, this morning when I woke up and thought of a new akross video, I fervently hoped it would be yours ;) I was rewarded! I love the changes you made, I thought they added to the video! Well you know what I think about the lack of concept in the video, but I understand your choice of releasing it the way you did! I love the editing, and my point still stands that with some (okay, you would have needed a lot) more time and manipulating, it could have been outstanding! I probably wouldn't have had the patience to do so either, though :p I'm looking forward to seeing what you'll release next ^^ Thanks for the 'thanks' by the way, you're always welcome <3
I know that you tried to sync the scenes with the music. And it's a good try. But the music consists of the main three parts that are verse, bridge, and chorus. Basically you must change the tone of the scenes by part. But you didn't do it. So your video is monotonous.
Толи м/в не подходит, то ли слишком плохой подбор сцен. В середине еще нормально. Tolley m/v is not appropriate, or too poor selection of scenes. In the middle is still normal. 4.5/10
escenas demasiado largas, no es interesante, a los 30 segundos ya no hay ganas de verlo, demasiados lips y escenas que no tienen nada que ver con la historia, tipica historia de amor con siempre el mismo anime hecho en 2 dias, mas originalidad porfavor, 4/10 aun asi es agradable ver editores espanoles en concursos asin, aun puedes mejorar mucho
прочитал пару комментов подумал: наверное что то хорошее сделали. Но посмотрев клип разочаровался: липс в некоторых местах корявый, кое-где видны хлопоротики, да и скучно было смотреть. О ЧЁМ ЭТО??? Оценка = 4
Нет, ну нет же! The Boy Who Murdered Love намного лучше! Да и шикарнейший Sincerity ещё есть. Так что как очередной клип на Hyouka данная работа не претендует ни на что!
This is called preconceived notion of "fake superiority", waiting for something subjectively "better" using the same source/music is irrelevant; if everyone started doing this, how people are going to be able to critic anime music videos seeing them as a standalone work? "Well, your video isn't better then that other one, so, I didn't liked" - this does not give your personal insight about anything, something that would be helpful (or not) to the author.
Tolley m/v is not appropriate, or too poor selection of scenes. In the middle is still normal. 4.5/10
Оценка = 4
This is called preconceived notion of "fake superiority", waiting for something subjectively "better" using the same source/music is irrelevant; if everyone started doing this, how people are going to be able to critic anime music videos seeing them as a standalone work? "Well, your video isn't better then that other one, so, I didn't liked" - this does not give your personal insight about anything, something that would be helpful (or not) to the author.
И о чем? Или нужно смотреть исходник, чтобы знать в чем дело?