The War is about a rebellion due to the disobedience to god that a male angel fell in love with a woman. ---some basic level of description can also be seen in the AMV though not until very late. In fact, half of the time, if you think this is an AMV simply talking about the anime Fate/Zero, I think it is still ok. At least this is what I intended to do initially, but I changed my plan for whatever reasons.
Side notes: Welcome to the world of 1/30 sec! It is my pleasure to join this community, and this is my first time to participate in an AMV contest. I sincerely hope you enjoy this project, or at least I do so. However, I also deeply feel that there is still a long way for me to achieve my expectation in this field. So far I have multiple projects on hold along with my busy university coursework. I hope next time I can go farther.
22.11.2017
Video
Various[ Fate/Zero, Chaos;Child, Aiyoku no Eustia, Angel Beats!, Eden, ef - a fairy tale of the two ]
Хороший клип. Довольно сильный с технической стороны, хотя местами откровенно перефифекченно, так например в самом начале (00.07) вот что это и зачем? что оно привносит в клип, что хочет сказать зрителю? Дальше таких откровенных фифектов ради фифектов нет, но близкого этому хвастовства "посмотри как Я могу" встречается много. (Я несколько раз позавидовал^^). Некоторая креативность по внесению в клип техничных финтифлюшек у автора есть. А вот клип "сам по себе" уже довольно прост. Хороший экшен, пожалуй даже с отличным (для экшена) м/в. Ни драмы, ни истории особо не приметил. Впрочем для окончательного вердикта надо бы и пересмотреть, но не тянет.
Kroner Oh, I am happy to listen to you guys' opinions. Sorry if my tone sounds like whatever. I just want to say I put some effects with meanings when you guys think they are meaningless/useless. So I end up thinking it depends on how you interpret them because we really have different perspectives on this issue. Sorry I don't know what else I should say when I really feel in that way.
BTW, one thing you reminds me pretty well that "even more cause they were too real for an animation". That's a pretty interesting opinion, and I will think more about that. Thank you.
Actually you can do what you want, but if someone want to judge, he must say what he thinks, and you can disagree with him but you also should think about what someone said. You are partecipating to a contest, so that mean that you're going to be judge and I don't think that senteces as "different sensibility makes a difference. After all, none of us is the king of the world." are correct in that way. We all have our own taste, but there are things correct and other less, your explosion were senseless cause they had no sense, but even more cause they were too real for an animation. You can do whatever you want, but I'm saying this not because I want to be an a**hole, but because we comment to help each other, and if I think something is wrong I must tell you, and you ofc can take it or not, just don't play hide and seek saying that everything is subjective
hmmm, sometimes I think it depends on how you interpret them. Nicokun said some effects were totally useless. I don't know what effects he exactly meant, but I assume he (and may other people) meant 1:13-1:18 and 2:03-2:08. If he said they were ugly, I neither want to debate nor to agree with him. However, if he and you mean that some effects were useless or unnecessary, at least I put them for whatever reasons.
I agree that just adding effects will not make AMV/MAD better, so this is not the major reason I added all these things.
For you, Kroner, you specifically pointed out the explosions. I only added two prominent explosions. I agree that the one around 0:17 has less meaning compared to the others. The other one around 0:55 has a solid meaning to me. If you don't have a clue what it can mean and if you want to know more about that, we can discuss that individually. Again, at least I personally put them for some reasons. I hope you like them or if you don't, I really feel sorry about that.
Also, different sensibility makes a difference. After all, none of us is the king of the world.
Why did you put all those effects? the raw parts were definitely better! All those explosions, glitchs were unnecessary, effects should be functional to the clip himself and not something you add just cause it's cool. Actually I think that the best effects are those who are difficult to notice, the silent one, cause they add something without cover the rest
+1, дичь
Oh, I am happy to listen to you guys' opinions. Sorry if my tone sounds like whatever.
I just want to say I put some effects with meanings when you guys think they are meaningless/useless. So I end up thinking it depends on how you interpret them because we really have different perspectives on this issue. Sorry I don't know what else I should say when I really feel in that way.
BTW, one thing you reminds me pretty well that "even more cause they were too real for an animation". That's a pretty interesting opinion, and I will think more about that. Thank you.
hmmm, sometimes I think it depends on how you interpret them.
Nicokun said some effects were totally useless. I don't know what effects he exactly meant, but I assume he (and may other people) meant 1:13-1:18 and 2:03-2:08. If he said they were ugly, I neither want to debate nor to agree with him. However, if he and you mean that some effects were useless or unnecessary, at least I put them for whatever reasons.
I agree that just adding effects will not make AMV/MAD better, so this is not the major reason I added all these things.
For you, Kroner, you specifically pointed out the explosions. I only added two prominent explosions. I agree that the one around 0:17 has less meaning compared to the others. The other one around 0:55 has a solid meaning to me. If you don't have a clue what it can mean and if you want to know more about that, we can discuss that individually. Again, at least I personally put them for some reasons. I hope you like them
Also, different sensibility makes a difference. After all, none of us is the king of the world.
8