| [21.12.2013] Tollos » tan(x) [lolligerjoj] | Into The Labyrinth мне как то больше понравился, и всё же это тоже мощная работа, которая заслужила свою заслуженную 9! |
|
| [21.12.2013] MouseBollocks » Blume des Bösen [Miso] | This portrayed some very complex emotions very well indeed. Very good video, despite the fact that the editing was occasionally a little jarring. |
|
| [21.12.2013] MouseBollocks » Drive Out [John] | I'll admit, I'm slightly disappointed. I really, really liked With Lightning Speed, and was excited to see your next video. However, I feel like this was a fairly standard "serious-action" video. The text was the main thing I liked about, as I thought the simplicity looked really cool at points. However, as someone who isn't a huge fan of this kind of video, I'm afraid I can't rate it as highly as I would have liked to, coming from you. |
|
| [21.12.2013] MouseBollocks » Circus [Angel_Sora] | Your editing was for the most part very good, and that camera work was pretty nice, but it feels like this video lacks any sort of idea or concept that defines it. It seems to largely just be pretty anime clips set to a song. There is no mood, or no theme, and that's what's dragging the video down. |
|
| [21.12.2013] InsanitySupporter » tan(x) [lolligerjoj] | This is a masterpiece if we talk about technic and visual design, and your concept is really interesting, but I feel something's missing... and it bored me, but maybe because I prefer "fast" videos... Still a unique piece |
|
| [21.12.2013] MouseBollocks » The Boy Who Murdered Love [ONEWAYS] | Fantastic stuff here. The concept is great, and the story strikes the balance between being clear and not too simple, but it's the backgrounds and graphics you made that make this a really special video. I particularly like how they occasionally reference the song's music video. The only thing I would point out is that the masking is occasionally a little lackluster, but I'm aware that Hyouka is a difficult show to mask accurately. Really good job overall, and good luck in the contest! |
|
| [21.12.2013] MouseBollocks » Undone [cero] | Agree with the person a few comments down. I wouldn't recommend entering a contest (Particularly AKROSS, as it's basically an elite contest) with your first video.
The video itself is honestly just a standard action AMV. I'm afraid that's all there really is to say on the matter. A good first attempt, however. |
|
| [21.12.2013] lolligerjoj » tan(x) [lolligerjoj] | Thanks to everyone giving their honest opinions :)
MouseBollocks @ 21 December 2013, 16:21 | |
I added the screen tearing because I wanted to sync certain sounds, but I also intended them to alienate the viewer from immersion, to give the feeling that something isn't right, which becomes obvious in the turning point towards the end. So far I didn't notice that anyone took it that way, so I guess it was a failed experiment. I still like them for syncing purposes though :) |
|
| [21.12.2013] Dioker » tan(x) [lolligerjoj] | Это самая необычная работа на данный момент!!! Очень атмосферно, оригинально, эффекты очень понравились!! Не к чему придраться даже)) 9.2 П.З.: там ближе к концу клипа, была показана рука, в каких-то белых соплях или это то о чем я подумал ???? |
|
| [21.12.2013] j7n13q » Gothic [ASiR] | ничего оригинального... таких амв на хелсинг наклепали уже... штабелями, 1 раз посмотрел и вспоминать не хочется
лучше бы сделали 1-2 работы но такие чтобы запомнились и захотелось сохранить на память |
|
|
| |
MOST ACTIVE VOTERS | 1. | | 1899 | 2. | | 1816 | 3. | | 1781 | 4. | | 1779 | 5. | | 1736 | 6. | | 1701 | 7. | | 1670 | 8. | | 1518 | 9. | | 1514 | 10. | | 1512 | 11. | | 1471 | 12. | | 1423 | 13. | | 1402 | 14. | | 1337 | 15. | | 1330 | 16. | | 1222 | 17. | | 1133 | 18. | | 1115 | 19. | | 1110 | 20. | | 1102 |
|
|