 | [29.01.2018] MycathatesyouAMV » Infidelity [David Heli] | | I love that you used NF. Cool video overall as well. I think the motion graphic and some of the other animes felt out of place though. Your video felt good enough, that I don't think it needed them. |
|
| [29.01.2018] MycathatesyouAMV » Be Somebody [Chaiberry] | | cool character profile. I think you could have slowed down the cuts at the slower parts of the song, and removed some of the lip flap, but overall the editing makes the video flow pretty well |
|
 | [29.01.2018] irriadin » Last fire fades [Bea$t] | As a great admirer of your past work, and someone who also finds Berserk and Claymore to be some of my favorite anime / manga respectively (by a long shot), I was VERY excited to see that you were covering dark souls. Initially, I have to admit, I was disappointed to not see any of the incredible motion design seen in your previous works.
Now that I've rewatched your video a few times, I can really appreciate your cuts, scene selection and overall interpretation of the haunting beauty and decay that is such a touchstone of the Souls series. The music was well-chosen (though the drums ARE a little much, even for me) and I felt a great sense of respect for the elements of great realms gone to ruin that Miyazaki places such importance in.
While there are other flashier GMVs using this source, I don't feel like any of them have felt like an extension of the vision of Souls like this one. I would have loved for some more dynamic camera motion and color grading, and more use of the Flame Keeper / Emerald Herald / Maiden in Black. Maybe even Artorias and Sif. Perhaps you wanted to keep things at a more macro-level distance, but I think I would have felt a greater connection to the video if you had shown some of them.
BUT if your intention was to focus on the Gwyn and the lords of cinder, you did a great job. Overall, I really like it. Good job! |
|
 | [29.01.2018] hamburgergerjoj » Dilemma [L33t] | | Please notice me daddy Danic you're so hot and classy gucci gucci guys from Nexus turn me on |
|
 | [29.01.2018] GoldenThunder » Dilemma [L33t] | first line: IVE BEEN FUKKIN HOESSSS
0:33 TINGLE SKRA TA TRAA TRAA while holding handz
/drama amv/ |
|
 | [29.01.2018] Hilary Cullen » Pending... [Xophilarus] | I don't even know how to properly articulate how much I liked this one. I'm addicted to it now. The song goes perfectly with the drama of the characters' lives, their suffering and then, juxtaposed with it all, the games and the mannequins/dolls/marionettes breaking apart... The hard cuts and fades are a perfect match to the song, and the overall editing is easy on the eyes (it's the most appropriate when we need to see what's happening as well, instead of being thrown around by flashy transitions and effects). It's as they say: sometimes, simple is best.  |
|
| [28.01.2018] irriadin » Soligain [AMVs Gimenez] | | You were very ambitious in your storytelling, but the blending and masks were not very good sometimes (especially that scene with the knife). Try to use saturation and color grading that matches your different sources. Also, softening edges can help a lot for blending a bit better. |
|
 | [28.01.2018] Kvant » City Ganker [HQ] | Противоречивые впечатления. Если бы у автора был бы сколь-нибудь пригодный концепт, а непросто навык и технический скил, то могло бы получится что-нибудь достойное. А так...
Клип имеет объём (художественное решение), но не имеет содержания (не обязательно смыслового). Одни прикольные фичи, тем более они тут однообразны, довольно скоро надоедают, ну, по крайней мере, лично мне.
00.49 
01.28 
Хотя, как фан, работа хороша.
---------------------
| sucubus @ 21 January 2018, 15:46 | | ох уж мне этот китайский юмор |
Боюсь что он не китайский ни разу. Был бы национальный, было бы что оценить, но не факт что мы смогли бы.
| KSANDR @ 21 January 2018, 16:26 | | в каком месте это фан? |
| ICEberg @ 21 January 2018, 16:41 | | каким местом тут фан? |
В монтаже, и в способе трансляции персонажей.
| T.K. @ 21 January 2018, 18:02 | | но вот жанр "FUN"... вероятно приколы были столь сложными что я не заметил |
Приколы свойственны жанру "комедия". Причем, обычно, плохим её вариантам. |
|
|
| |
|
|  | FLCL |
|  | Ежи и Петруччо - Собак |
|  | Psychedelic |
|
|
|
|
one of my contest favorites, good luck !
