 | [21.11.2016] saned » Apathy [Gta iv86] |  تبآ لك
akross عبالي بيطلع فيديو يستحق المشاركه في موقع
وكلفتني فقط البس السماغات لجل استمع و اشوف شي جميل لكن مع الاسف .سياء جدآ
لكن مضحك 
الفن مش طرح فيديو له بدايه و نهايه الفن ان تحط فيديو تبهر الجميع .
بان ينتقدونك
وهذا اللي انا اشوفه في المقطع الخاص بك
انك مقدم مقطع لكي تستقبل انتقادات الجميع 
ان شاء الله يكون لي نصيب في سنه القادمه الاني قاعد اتعلم على عمل
AMV 
1:10  هذا الي يستاهله المقطع |
|
 | [21.11.2016] Gta iv86 » Apathy [Gta iv86] | buggy
yeaaah, if you actually commented constructive criticism instead of comparing me to other authors that would be great. |
|
 | [20.11.2016] MrNosec » Numinous [MrNosec] | | Artofeel @ 20 November 2016, 17:56 | | |
You seem somewhat upset about my video, but that's completely fine, that's your opinion and I respect it, I'm not here to argue with anyone.
I don't think the songs I used have anything in common with his videos, he never used EDM or Dubstep, and I've never seen him use a single scene from the Eva rebuilds, not to mention scene selection is heavily limited when using twixtor.
It's also ludicrously amusing how there are hundreds of ecchi/fun/action/romance editors whose style is exactly the same as everyone else's, and nobody bats an eye, but when I do anything slightly reminiscent of lolligerjoj, a style I enjoy and adapted with my own ideas and concept, everyone loses their minds.
In all honesty, these comparisons lead nowhere and from my perspective don't even count as constructive criticism, because in the end you're not talking about the video itself, you're simply comparing it to other videos.
Anyways, thanks for being honest about it, even if our points of view are divergent. |
|
 | [20.11.2016] frosta » Apathy [Gta iv86] | Why can't I give less then 1/10 ? this deserve WAY less....
but more seriously :
1) how does this passed the tech check up ?
2) how could the author made that and think : this is good enough for an akross video lets do it!
3) HOW can it be in a 1:15 video a black screen of 8 consecutive seconds ? that roughly 10% of the video.
4) how it is possible that this amv has no technical, stylish effect or kind of theme in it?
Questions over questions....
1/10 and I'm gentle! But also something positive youre good at color mixing and color correction.
Better luck next time and I hope also more skill.
PS: Learn first how to do an actual good looking AMV/GMV before participing in a contest. |
|
 | [20.11.2016] sucubus » Apathy [Gta iv86] | | удивительно, что такую работу приняли, ведь сам клип идёт меньше минуты |
|
 | [20.11.2016] buggy » Apathy [Gta iv86] | | yeeahh, if people could use their own editing style that would be great |
|
 | [20.11.2016] Artofeel » Numinous [MrNosec] | MrNosec man...
you have titles like lolligerjoj
your scene selection like lolligerjoj
your music selection like lolligerjoj ©
what are you bullshiting?
find yourself. |
|
| [20.11.2016] MrNosec » Numinous [MrNosec] | Artofeel
It seems like me using twixtor to make an AMV is all it takes to instantly be using a style someone else apparently owns, but hey it's understandable, not many people make videos like this so comparisons are inevitable. |
|
| [20.11.2016] Artofeel » Numinous [MrNosec] | | MrNosec @ 20 November 2016, 20:53 | | but to me, the number one goal of an AMV should be to fit the visuals to the audio as best as possible and create a coherent audiovisual experience that represents the music visually |
and using for this someone else style?
what a waste of time and skills...
| MrNosec @ 20 November 2016, 20:53 | | the major reason for that is because I used 25Mbps bitrate instead of the standard 10Mbps for 1080p |
use normal encoder, like x254\x265, with --crf parameter.
there is no need to force specific bitrate, it's archaism. |
|
| [20.11.2016] MrNosec » Numinous [MrNosec] | Thanks everyone for taking your time to watch and write a comment, I've read them all and really appreciate it!
| Artofeel @ 20 November 2016, 10:27 | | |
I understand what you mean by the "lack of meaning", the whole narrative/plot stuff, some people do find it easier to watch AMVs with them, but to me, the number one goal of an AMV should be to fit the visuals to the audio as best as possible and create a coherent audiovisual experience that represents the music visually. Sometimes this is done as a narrative, sometimes not, but I in the end it's still what's it's called, a music video.
Apologies for the absurd file size of the alternative version, the major reason for that is because I used 25Mbps bitrate instead of the standard 10Mbps for 1080p, not to mention the 60fps equals more than double the size of most amvs, it was the best approach to avoid any pixelation on gradients and on scenes I used Lens Blur to simulate DOF because of the fast paced nature of the video.
I am sure you knew all this as you are quite experienced compared to me, but I feel like I owed you at least a justification, thanks for the recommendation and encouraging words! |
|
 | [20.11.2016] MesoGear » Apathy [Gta iv86] | попахивает сговором, фанаты лоли решили что ли захватить мир?
ах да! клип, халтурка |
|
|
| |
|
|  | Amazing Nuts!, Lucky Star, Magical Shopp… |
|  | Various |
|  | MEP, Dance |
|
|
|
|
ИМХО БРЕД.. и именно с большой буквы
