 | [28.01.2015] ICEberg » Rule [-Mikami-] | Задумка неплоха
Начало неплохо
Девочка с яблоком неплоха
Но реализация невытянута - как-то слишком затянуто и однообразно либо слишком много разных персонажей
Сократить вдвое - и атмосферу удалось бы сохранить
Местами синхра плывет
Может это и авторская задумка - но разноаспектное видео и эти самые поля дополнительно убивают реализацию
Экшен хромает на обе лапы
Романтика... ну формально местами для смотревших канон...
Психодела не увидел совсем |
|
 | [28.01.2015] andrewbee » User Distortion [Rider4Z] | | Watched this again and really enjoyed the pacing in the video. The hurt like most have mentioned, comes from the length of the track. Editing the music to a shorter length would have allowed this amv to hit a very sweet spot with the tribute. It certainly got me to add the anime to my 'must see' list so for that, wish you the best of luck! :) |
|
 | [28.01.2015] ZnPe » Lose Love [Aoimina] | | Бред ....музыка старая,синхронизации нету...даже смотреть после половины не стал |
|
 | [28.01.2015] FadingSundown » Touching Hearts [FadingSundown] | | Bufer, I know that AMV is complicated, and I've learned a lot but always find that I'm never done learning. For me, I do find the song fitting and I like it, but I understand that some people can find this song to be bland, it has a happy tune all the way through, not much change, and even the singing probably doesn't suit the taste of some. Not everyone likes the same, which is good, but I can't do anything nor relate to a comment that just says 'boring' ;). As with most things, it is all personal opinions and different perpectives, so thank you for your honest view on my amv :) |
|
 | [28.01.2015] Bufer » Touching Hearts [FadingSundown] | actually the song made this video boring, i admit that in some way this song suits the video, but i dont think many people will like it
I personally unlikely will ever watch this again even if i beleive that what i've just saw was good. AMV is a complicated stuff you know, some things you will learn with time, even i cant describe it properly , so you probably won't get it in the perspective that i wanted
good luck :) |
|
 | [28.01.2015] iKuro » The End [AiLioNs] | me intereso al principio. Pero si no me equivoco usaste escenas del amv de otra persona.
Muy mal ahi u.u |
|
| [28.01.2015] Bufer » Cosmological Embrace [JSK] | well that was quite good :)
liked the sync and technical stuff, unfortunately didnt like the song though
anyway good work, good luck |
|
| [27.01.2015] FadingSundown » Touching Hearts [FadingSundown] | Hello people, this is my first international contest and I am happy to be on the Akross site. For the commentators, if you think I am rude or if you feel like I am insulting you, I apologize, this is not my intention at all. I want to learn from comments, and not be left wondering why you felt that my video was boring/bad.
nivekov123, nail46 and FunnyMan, I'm glad you liked it! skyrim, thank you for your nice words, and I appreciate the high rating. akira02sum, thank you : )! Their music is beautiful.
InsanitySupporter and Darksss 73, I do not think that Wolf Children is that easy to use, the story is difficult to portray properly, especially for the people that have not seen the movie. That AMVs using certain sources are well known/well placed on contests doesn't make another amv using the same source less in default. If it is a good edit, why would it be less than an equally well edited amv using a lesser-used/known source? That would be the same as saying that every madoka amv is easy to make, because the footage is epic anyways. Which is not the case at all.
Sorry for my long replies, but I want to make sure there are no miscommunications. If you want to discuss anything with me about what I said, or talk about different opinions, please PM me :). |
|
|
| |
| AKROSS CON NOMINATIONS WON | | 1. | | 12 | | 2. | | 10 | | 3. | | 9 | | 4. | | 8 | | 5. | | 7 | | 6. | | 7 | | 7. | | 6 | | 8. | | 6 | | 9. | | 6 | | 10. | | 5 | | 11. | | 5 | | 12. | | 5 | | 13. | | 5 | | 14. | | 5 | | 15. | | 5 | | 16. | | 5 | | 17. | | 5 | | 18. | | 5 | | 19. | | 5 | | 20. | | 5 |
|
|
|  | Shikabane Hime Aka, Tales of the Abyss |
|  | Blue Stahli - The Pure and The Tainted |
|  | Action, Character Profile, Instrumental |
|
|
|
| | Nyan Koi |
| | Mindless Self Indulgence - Never Wanted To … |
| | Comedy / Fun |
|
|
|
|
