 | [06.12.2022] Krystal Kitty » Tears of Themis AMV Sugar [Krystal Kitty] | | Kvant @ 21 November 2022, 09:39 | Миленько, симпатично, приятно, но не более.
Сосредоточение на мужской сексуальности даёт клипу определённой привкус, он бы был интересен если бы вокруг такого (условно яойного) добра не было бы в таком избытке. Надо было это куда-то развивать, как-то оригинальничать, а куда и как не понятно.
Для меня самым большим минусом стал совершенно отвратительный (имха, разуметься) муз. трек. |
Because I'm running your comment through google translate, there may be slight errors but im gonna reply to the bulk of your words as much as possible
[Too much focus on males] - This is an OTOME game tribute, obviously its gonna feature focus on the main Males you encounter, hence the 4 boys you see. Saying there should not be an excess of them is utterly stupid because it stays true to the purpose of it being this game tribute. You are obviously not the target audience for this genre of AMV but saying its horrible/too much focus is a low-blow and not well intended.
[Disgusting Song choice] - Song is Sugars by Maroon 5 and fits this video clips to lyrics very well, If you don't understand the english lyrics due to the language barrier , that is fine but don't go saying its bad just cos you can't see how well it fits the video clips. I watched a couple of your own productions e.g your 2018 amv and I hate the songs you used as well, but i don't go commenting how horrible they are because I don't understand the lyrics and i'm not your target audience.
Before judging other people work, at least take into consideration the context of the video. - If you are not the target audience nor its language, take it with a pinch of hard salt that you are judging it unfairly already. Rude comments are not helping the editors and instead just comes off as berating. |
|
 | [03.12.2022] sucubus » COYOTE [Deviant] | | dumtumdum @ 02 декабря 2022, 19:48 | | местами блевануло |
какими местами? |
|
 | [02.12.2022] Darksss 73 » COYOTE [Deviant] | Думал будет Ru.Comix для взрослых а получил разочарование. 
Если 01:16 - 02:05 часть выглядит более менее - то остальное скатилось в полный трешь и херню.  |
|
 | [29.11.2022] NIGHT » [Eren·Jaeger] Dream and Disaster | 梦想·浩劫 [Reiner-Braun] | Movie trailer. Frankly speaking, here I can duplicate my comment on the last video...
...and just to add that there is noticeable banding (Posterization) - 00:03, 00:36 etc...
a vertical border appears and disappears from the left edge of the video, it is very noticeable
02:39 - the red color of the logo superimposed on the video looks bad (in fact, red could be replaced with blue - the main thing is that the inscription is clearly and clearly read)
lipsynk - the audio does not match the lip movement in the video sequence (when it hits, and when it doesn't)
in the case of using different special effects, highlights, amplification or color changes - you need to try to bring it all to a single denominator so that nothing stands out from the overall picture.
But in principle, if you gradually remove all sorts of technical inaccuracies, the author should get good works |
|
| [27.11.2022] Darksss 73 » Cataclysm [Xenova9000] | Из плюсов = понравился постер и путные моменты в синхрульку.
Из минусов = кислотные фефекты и несуразица в монтаже.
Но как экшен = вполне неплохо. Удачи в конкурсе.
Of the advantages = I liked the poster and the confusing moments in the synchrule.
Of the minuses = acid fefects and absurdity in installation.
But as an action = pretty good. Good luck with the competition. |
|
| [24.11.2022] NIGHT » Cataclysm [Xenova9000] | Мелкие технические огрехи в монтаже.
Очень плохое качество звука в стандартной версии клипа.
Перегруженность видеоряда "засветами", "бликами" и "усилением цвета".
Стремление автора подогнать монтаж (видеонарезку) под быстрый техно-ремикс электронной музыки... с одной стороны, в этом нет ничего плохого. С другой стороны - под такой вариант подойдёт только чистый экшн , а не всё то, что автор попытался показать в клипе.
Итог: потенциал у автора хороший. Но в дальнейших работах, нужно найти то, что будет "цеплять" зрителя.
Minor technical flaws.
Very poor sound quality in the standard version of the clip.
The overload of the video sequence with "highlights", "glare" and "color enhancement".
The author's desire to adjust the editing (video cutting) to a fast techno remix of electronic music... on the one hand, there is nothing wrong with this. On the other hand, only pure ACTION is suitable for this option, and not everything that the author tried to show in the clip.
Bottom line: the potential of the author is good. But in further works, you need to find something that will "catch" the viewer. |
|
| [23.11.2022] NIGHT » Game Over [Rika Sudzuki] | Эпично, но как-то слишком шаблонно... слишком.
При этом, чисто с технической, а если быть точным - с механической точки зрения, придирок к клипу у меня нет.
Итог: эпично, механично, скучно. |
|
| [23.11.2022] NIGHT » [Erwin·Smith] Choices Between Dream And Death | 梦与死的抉择 [Erwin-Smith] | Чуть грубоватый монтаж. И, на мой взгляд, чрезмерная перегрузка событиями и аудиорядом... не смотревшим это аниме будет сложно "вникнуть" в подаваемый автором материал.
A little rough editing... And, as it seems to me, excessive overload of events and audio order... for people who have not watched this anime's - it is difficult to "delve" into the material submitted by the author. |
|
|
| |
SilentMan
MY SUPER GIRLFRIEND |
|
|  | Birdy the Mighty Decode, Birdy the Mighty De… |
|  | Theory Of A Deadman - Bad Girlfriend |
|  | Story, Action |
|
|
Vlad G. Pohnert
TRANSCENDING LOVE |
|
| | Cowboy Bebop, Macross Plus, City Hunter |
| | Sarah Brightman - Only an Ocean Away |
| | Romance, Drama |
|
|
|
|
.gif){kind=avatar}
