AKROSS » Комментарии »





Регистрация Забыли пароль?

КОММЕНТАРИИ

1«158415851586158715881589159015911592»6615

[11.01.2014] Shiver » Arcade [ImGoing]

I think that the the type of editing you used, especially in the first half, didn't fit with the song. It was too fast and the clips were randomly put together.

[11.01.2014] botdru » What I Fight For [JSK]

Great!

[11.01.2014] EnIgMoZz2 » Antithesis [Enigmo]

AnimeFanaticBoy @ 10 January 2014, 20:44

What you're saying makes no sense and is completely irrelevant to anything I'm saying. As I say in the description of this video, the well-thought conclusion I have come down to is that in a music video, the purpose of the video is to reflect the audio, and that also includes the beat of the music. I mean, the cases where the audio represents the video, are trailers for example, where they add sound effects over the music so there is still some audio and video link. And also, in basically short-movies where the music can be seen as "background music", for example in EvilSpider - Revenge and that crossover AMV from 2002 or something called Dragon Bebop Z.

Show me a hardcut edited music video/trailer that you think I won't think matches my description of "hardcuts", just so you can prove your point.

AnimeFanaticBoy @ 10 January 2014, 20:44

Btw, I already reached my goal today and I'm surprised you havent noticed yet :lol:

Honestly, this is just a way of you trying to crawl out of an argument you already lost. You're going to say something like, "all I wanted to do was make you waste your time." Come on, that's baby stuff - anyone on my level of intellect knows that's the typical way of a person who's trying to run away from a lost argument - try something new. And in all honesty, I started it with you, so if anything, it's me who got you to waste your time. I mean, you're spending as much time here as me.

Added (after 10 min. and 7 sec.):

Also, your message suggests all I did to make my videos look like they had good hardcut editing was by syncing it to music. Well, that last, "bad" one syncs to the music, but I can distinguish its level of hardcut editing from the others. Your points are invalid, accept that.

[10.01.2014] AnimeFanaticBoy » Antithesis [Enigmo]

Nop. You can listen to a song and you can determine where the synch can go.... unfortunately it's not the law all the cases, since every song has a different way to work with a hardcut.

Btw, I already reached my goal today and I'm surprised you havent noticed yet :lol:

[10.01.2014] EnIgMoZz2 » Antithesis [Enigmo]

Do you understand what intuition is? You yourself said, you don't know how to say what a good hardcut video will look like - you can only see whether it's good or not. That's what intuition is. Though it may sound like I've simplified it, trust me, intuition is not a simplistic concept. And I don't know what a hardcut is? Well, I mean, now I just feel challenged. If you were to, let's say, "AMV battle" me and the condition was for both of us to edit completely raw, who would you say is more likely to win? :) But of course, come down to that conclusion after you've watched the videos.

I'm not trying to make you feel bad about yourself, notice how usually I..... nevermind, maybe I'll write a novel about how altruistic I am some other time.

[10.01.2014] cokAMVs » Quiet [Okami]

Domius
Caro Domius, gran critico di amv, a 0:51 Rei si vede per una frazione di secondo, SI CAZZO UNA FRAZIONE DI SECONDO, la scena è l'esplosione! Non Rei che per notarla bisognerebbe fermare l'immagine! Tra l'altro se dovessimo fare i pignoli, Domius, c'è pure Misato per terra a 0:51, come hai fatto a non notarla? Il tuo occhio non è riuscito a notare questo OBBROBRIO?

Per quanto riguarda la presenza di Rei a 1:02 e 2:20 è voluto. Rei non è un protagonista, ha solo funzione di osservatore che se la ride per ciò che accade. Se noti Rei è presentata nello stesso modo.

A 1:35 Misato non ha ruolo, se vedi è girata e non si è mai vista in tutto il video. Piuttosto ho preferito inserire quella scena perchè mi piaceva come era disegnata la faccia di Shinji ed erano presenti delle mani (un elemento che ripeto in tutto il video, non è la stessa scena) che li coprivano il viso.

La scena finale di Shinji alla fine dura 25 secondi perchè io ho voluto così, non posso? :P Se ci pensi un attimo forse riuscirai a capire il perchè di quella scena e il motivo della sua impostazione.

Le scene sono state sempre riproposte in modo diverso, Yusuke ci ha rivisto 3 volte una scena, quando in realtà l'ho utilizzata solo due volte in modi diversi, tu dici che ho usato 4 volte la scena della lingua quando in realtà effettivamente l'ho usata solo una volta a 1:47 (l'altra è in una sfumata che dura meno di una frazione di secondo).
Oltre a questi due casi vi prego di farmi notare qualche altra frazione di secondo in cui si ripetono delle scene :D

Per quanto riguarda la climax non sto a spiegarti che cos'è visto che tu e yusuke non avete ben chiaro il concetto e dettate spiegazioni tecniche.

Comunque piuttosto che fare questi commenti da gran professionisti della tecnica preferirei che facciate come PrincessKairy, grazie.

[10.01.2014] AnimeFanaticBoy » Antithesis [Enigmo]

Intuition? really?

That's all you need to say?

Then again, you dont know yet what a hardcut is

[10.01.2014] AnimeFanaticBoy » What I Fight For [JSK]

Hey, gracias por los agradecimientos, en verdad gracias :gigi:

En resumen: La tipografia del inicio.... No. Me extraña porque a partir del 0:49 se puso interesante. Hubieras agregado la categoria Manga (La categoria existe pero casi no se menciona) a los generos.

En general veo que dependes mas que todo de los zooms y aunque eso no es malo, puede llegar a aburrir despues del minuto

[10.01.2014] EnIgMoZz2 » Antithesis [Enigmo]

AnimeFanaticBoy @ 10 January 2014, 19:56

I'll only reply to the first paragraph, the next two feel irrelevant.

Wait, so I mean, if you think you've not met an editor who can do hardcuts, where have you seen hardcuts? Instead of actually replying to what you say directly, I'll just explain my "theories/philosophies". With hardcuts, either you can do it, or you can't. There's no technique to it - it's all about intuition; this entire style is about intuition and perception. And 12 years making AMVs? So? Experience means nothing, compared to a mind intelligent enough to see the connections a lot quicker. I'll just post a bunch of links of my hardcut works and if you tell me after watching them that I can't do hardcuts and shouldn't talk about them, "me, especially", then I'll just be convinced that you're simply copying what some other editor, who you think is smart, already said.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BHvs-Xh8YWI
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GrtanNCjFVY
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5D1dmP9zMTY
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jrxUe3BeMdM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2vpais5XOKw
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=40hJv8B8jk8
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=06OL7IBENkc
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mKiydAWAhGg
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZCZKGW1K_cY
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GJ8Zytsl5rQ

Obviously you don't have to watch them (I still have a lot more, lol) but I mean, all those links should get the message across that I know I can do it.

If you're wondering: "Wait, if all of those are hardcut AMVs you think are good hardcuts, where's a video I can look at that has hardcuts, but bad ones?"
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Sl8idZCMyE

All of the ones at the top feel right, and the bad one just doesn't feel right - that's what intuition is. And if you have 12 years of video editing experience, you should by now have developed a sense of perception that can see the difference.

Added (after 3 min. and 1 sec.):

And if you want, after, I can send you my favourite "hardcut" music videos by editors other than myself, just so you understand what I have isn't just vanity for my own work, but appreciation for a very intelligent style.

[10.01.2014] Ellfin » what is Life [Mariel]

приятный психодельчик получился (драмы увы я не увидела), технически топорно и фон поздравительной открытки не понравился, но идея отличная.

[10.01.2014] AnimeFanaticBoy » Antithesis [Enigmo]

Your wishes are granted then.

You ask me what do I mean by: Talking about hardcuts.
To be honest, I havent meet yet an editor that can do the hardcuts. All of us pretend to say what they understand or what they believe how a hardcut should be made. Neither any famous editor has reached it. And trust me man, that in almost 12 years I have making AMVs I have watched yet. Why? Because there's no actual 'guide' or 'theory' about how a hardcut should be made. I'm nihilistic on this because the AMV tendecy changes every day. You cant really expect AMVs to be into a static change, but in a continuos and dynamic change.

This is how this AMVWorld works: We watch several videos and we start to believe that a video should be made into a certain way. Like you said earlier, there are videos that are actually good but several people tends to bash them due their songs, anime selected or the genre. And that's true, you cant deny that fact. While this will work in people that normally is new, fanboy, or any other people that dont know what they are talking about, there's always people that is interested in giving interesting criticism... into a constructive way of course.

Perhaps you might be mad with the people that just want to troll you. This is a situation of every day, trust me. Or you might be able to actually listen to what they really have to say and not just their intentions. This is when you detect a person just want to argue for nothing or really help you