 | [15.01.2017] Kvant » Home [Marykiddo] | | Миленький, простенький клип о романтических чувствах в волшебной стране. Неплохо, но не более. Есть подозрения на интересную лирику, но гуглить лень. |
|
| [15.01.2017] Kvant » Frozen Dreams [bbsnypur] | Очень даже неплохо.
Из трех заявленных категорий есть только данс. (Имхо, пора для таких клипов вводить категорию "спорт").
Клип пересматривать буду вряд ли, но теперь наверняка как-нибудь попробую попробовать анимешку. На том и спасибо) |
|
 | [15.01.2017] AnimeFanaticBoy » Tragic Vampire Story [ingrid97] | Repasemos las bases:
En un primer lugar, la seleccion de escenas no encaja. Pero se ve que hay una intencion y no como una obra desordenada. Los efectos hay que planearlos mejor para la proxima.
A proposito, hay una comunidad para editores latinoamericanos llamada ZonaAMV por si quieres mejorar |
|
 | [15.01.2017] MrNosec » Tragic Vampire Story [ingrid97] | It's not bad for your first try, but it seems like you tried to do more flashy stuff rather than getting the basics down first tho.
The scene selection feels very unplanned and doesn't fit the music from my perspective, some internal sync is cool, like Ararararagi hitting the wall @ 2:26
The vertical-glitchy-effect-thingy just didn't work for me, it's not synced to any specific sound and it appears randomly throughout the whole video (it doesn't look all that good either), this is an example where having no effects would have actually made the video better, the zoom transitions were an OK idea, but should be used sparingly and when the scenes in between justify it.
The encoding also has some issues, it's 60fps with no interpolation which means it has alot more repeated frames (making it look more stuttery) and more than double the file size it should have, bitrate is 2Mbps, quite terrible, specially for a vid encoded at 60fps, and other mundane stuff like only having 1 ReFrame and so on.
You were not supposed to know all this of course, you're just starting out, and maybe you don't even give a shit  and that's fine too, but I left my fussy and pedantic fault-finding opinion anyway so you can do more and better on your next projects, good luck with those! |
|
 | [15.01.2017] Axel d'Arc » Home [Marykiddo] | Marykiddo
Sorry it took me so long to reply,the parts where the anime has it's original color not the enchanted one (for example at 0:24 - 0:25) when Zen jumps up),i think a little color correction would make it blend better as a whole.Also did you edited this in Vegas ? I can see some ghosting,next time select Disable Resample on your videos when you put them into the timeline, (I may be wrong about the ghosting since i'm not that good at spotting it xD)
And since i came back and watched the video again i got to like the amv and the song more than i did the first time xD. |
|
 | [14.01.2017] Maniaki » Epiphany [UnluckyArtist] | Haha... This I enjoyed. Although its far from being perfect and lacks attention to details and craftsmanship, this is probably the most enjoyable thing I've watched for far too long and solely for one reason - style and freedom. I'm bookmarking you.
P.S i've only watched 30% of entries of this year's contestants so I'm hoping for more. |
|
 | [14.01.2017] TrueAmv » BORSCH [TrueAmv] | MrNosec
Thank you for giving extensive review. I will definitely take advantage of good advice.
I'm an aspiring writer, so not very well appeal to video editing. At the same time I was very limited in time, so did not have time to remove all artifacts. Next
P.S. Sorry for my bad English. (I used online translator).
P.P.S. Good luck. |
|
 | [14.01.2017] Folrog » Loser Style [EVOsvik] | | Хорошо, не сказать, чтобы зацепило, но сюжетная линия понятна, досмотрел до конца, клип раздражения не вызывал. Даже исходник поискал. |
|
| [14.01.2017] MrNosec » Epiphany [UnluckyArtist] | Really enjoyed this, surely one of the best psychedelic vids in this year's akross.
Even if the sudden changes between smooth 60fps interpolated footage and typical non-interpolated animation felt jarring at times, I must say it works in favor of the psychedelic concept, even if it wasn't your intention, very unorthodox but quite effective when you look at the video as a whole.
Good luck in the contest  |
|
|
| |
| THE HIGHEST NUMBER OF VOTES | |
|
|  | Kodomo no Jikan |
|  | D.C. OST |
|  | Drama |
|
|
|
|
