Here's my first entry ever. Don't expect too much, it's not my fiirst amv but I'm not so talented.
I decided to make a simple tribute to my favorite manga: Magico. I l wanted to capture Shion's development through the story, and I used this songs because I think it fits the fact that Shion always will protect his beloved Emma and his friends.
Please, be honest, I hope to learn a lot with your comments.
Я уж испугался, что в этом году не будет адекватных клипов по манге. Получилось отлично. Очень милое и атмосферное AMV. Технически тоже всё понравилось. Конечно до уровня BEAST WITHIN тут пахать и пахать, но свои 7.8/10 от себя поставлю =)
MMVs are hard and need a lot of practice and creativity to make them something 'special'. I have a couple of friends who are seriously amazing mmv editors, so I will have to rate your video based on that. I don't think it is bad at all, and I can see talent in terms of flow (at parts) and ideas. But it's still mediocre. Next time, try to focus more on diversity, in your video there are many repetitive scenes and movements. Also, if you decide to have narrating text, I wouldn't add any lyrics of the song, it's confusing and a bit too much. Well, this is only my personal opinion. Keep it up ^^
I apologize, but I don't like this editing style. Manga editing is very difficult and becomes quite boring to me if not properly animated beyond still image pans. The text makes it even worse; I feel as thought it lacks creativity when it comes to lyric matching. However, this is just my own opinion and others seem to appreciate the work so don't get too down. I only critique since I actually watched it. Good luck!
'special'. I have a couple of friends who are seriously amazing mmv editors, so I will have to rate your video based on that. I don't think it is bad at all, and I can see talent in terms of flow (at parts) and ideas. But it's still mediocre. Next time, try to focus more on diversity, in your video there are many repetitive scenes and movements. Also, if you decide to have narrating text, I wouldn't add any lyrics of the song, it's confusing and a bit too much. Well, this is only my personal opinion. Keep it up ^^
7