| [06.03.2015] Whiterock » Nefarium Psychologica [Shin] | I think I miss what people find so great about this. The video and song go each other's way, having madoka in source doesn't make video automatically psychodelic. Drama? Can't see it, there is no story or theme to show it. |
|
| [06.03.2015] Whiterock » GEHIRNSTURMEN [lolligerjoj] | So, almost six minutes of one small set of effects in different order and combination featuring big amount of gore. Well, we can see that you can synch things for this music well. But - psychodelic? Hardly, more like epileptic's worst nightmare. Horror? Probably, lots of gore afterall. But generally, six minutes of nothing, but just reptative effects. |
|
| [06.03.2015] Whiterock » Fatal/Game [ZEVS1993] | The crossover with alt story is amazing, sadly the lyrics of the song don't go together with video. |
|
| [06.03.2015] Whiterock » KNOW YOUR ENEMY [hiroki_999] | I still can't understand how this got a reward. At all. What's the fun in here? In the big amount of text? In totally unrelated music and video? In loads of girls dancing and singing without lypsynch? With the lyrics of the song you could have made a video how several girls which aim to be idols backstab, betray and outmatch each other to be the winner. |
|
| [05.03.2015] Whiterock » Serein [slimed] | Great story, especially accounting what you made it out of. Yet song goes separatedly from the video. |
|
| [05.03.2015] Whiterock » Lucky Seven [PieandBeer] | Fine enough, but at some point music and story lose each other. And missed good opportunity to use 7 characters of the series in combo with lyric's text. |
|
| [05.03.2015] Whiterock » The Sky's The Limit [Kis@] | The music/video combination is well-made, but seriously, why trying to fir more of studio Ghibli anime just for the sake of it? |
|
| [05.03.2015] Whiterock » Only your hand [Erdaicao] | Erdaicao @ 01 January 2015, 20:10 | but I try to avoid doing the same with him |
Not hard enough, like, not at all. |
|
| [05.03.2015] Whiterock » bitter sis love [FY.DUCK] | Too many flaws with lyrics for shown story, only half of the moments are made good. Effort is seen, <Unless> you knew about "Ballad of the Nice Guy" in the first place, but then again, you should have googled AMVs that used that song already. |
|
| [05.03.2015] Whiterock » Fate [DarkFlameCat] | Really well done, unfortunately came as 2nd trailer for Fate, and people usually tend to compare the works due to that, without judjing each piece on it's own. |
|
|
| |
|