 | [15.12.2013] Тёмыч-кун » Brutal Revolution [Benjamin] | | Ощущение, будто картинка растянута... или мне кажется? Ну в общем-то ничего выдающегося нету, да и ошибки присутствуют, атмосфера слабенькая. "Так себе". |
|
 | [15.12.2013] PrincessKairy » Downfall: Absolution [diegao94] | Kristoo
Sincerely, I don't mind if you like my video or not, surely I don't cry for a vote of an incompetent like you, and we can see that you're clearly incompetent from the fact that you're voting bad all the good videos and voting well all the bad ones. I state, I'm not saying that those videos are good to force (mine included), but everyone except you - little ant among the humans - is voting them well. Back to andrewbee's video, maybe you didn't understand yet that his video was published before the Akross premiere, thing prohibited by rules. I'm sorry for andrewbee, but these are the rules and we have to respect them, and he has willingly accepted the consequences of his mistake.
Feel free to avoid to reply me, because I haven't time to loose with you, little ant. |
|
 | [14.12.2013] Anicsi » Downfall: Absolution [diegao94] | | Kristoo @ 14 December 2013, 16:22 | Я конечно всё понимаю, но 90% авторов выкладывали свои клипы в соц сетях как на прошлогоднем конкурсе, так и на этом. И удалять действительно хороший клип, зря. Так можно и половину удалить, а конкурс должен показывать искусство. Эта работа очевидно слабее.
Sorry, but this situation is unpleasant to me. Still 1/10. |
I understand your feeling of sadness that a possibly good video was eliminated, but I don't think it is fair to give a rating like this a competitor's video just because of that. We are supposed to objectively evaluate and rate the entered videos. Of course personal taste will always play a minor role, but it's not supposed to affect the rating on such a scale. Even just looking at the editing would immediately overrule a rating of 1, considering it would be an amateur's video. I'm just saying.... it's unfortunate enough that they had to go for the same source, the least diegao deserves from us, is an honest rating. |
|
 | [14.12.2013] Kristoo » Brutal Revolution [Benjamin] | | Техника простовата. Переходы, эффекты как будто на Windows Move Maker делалось. Но в целом даже синхра прослеживается, это конечно не идеал, но думаю автор может добиться многого в будущем. 6/10 |
|
| [14.12.2013] Kristoo » Downfall: Absolution [diegao94] | PrincessKairy, assessment of your nasty AMV you can see in the comments, there is nothing to change.
About this AMV. Everyone can download it and put it on YouTube.
This year there were very few really good clips. this explains my behavior, I feel sorry for a good clip of andrewbee. |
|
 | [14.12.2013] AnimeFanaticBoy » Downfall: Absolution [diegao94] | This discussion feels like: Hey I watched those scenes already in 300 videos later, that's not original.
Can't you just sit down, relax and enjoy the video already? |
|
| [14.12.2013] PrincessKairy » Downfall: Absolution [diegao94] | Kristoo
The video was eliminated becaue it was violating contest's rules, and andrewbee admitted his faults. He asked to the coordinators about that and they decided to disqualify him from the competition.
Since diegao94 has no faults about that you should know how to judge a video for what it is and not making comparisons or comments like this "И удалять действительно хороший клип, зря". Therefore, you should give the vote you think it really deserves and stop beying a child like that.
Now show me your immaturity coming to my video and modifying your vote because I've disputed you ;) |
|
|
| |
| THE HIGHEST NUMBER OF VOTES | |
|
|  | Hyakko! |
|  | Linkin Park - Hole |
|  | Opening |
|
|
|
|
